The Night of the Hunter and a directing career of one
The Night of the Hunter (1955) was Charles Laughton's only feature film as director. Robert Mitchum played Harry Powell, a criminal presenting himself as a preacher, opposite Shelley Winters as Willa Harper and Lillian Gish as Rachel Cooper. An adaptation of Davis Grubb's novel, it placed a widow and her children in the path of a man pursuing stolen money. The BFI identifies its intensely visual storytelling with expressive black-and-white photography. Powell's hands carry the words LOVE and HATE, a pair of opposing labels incorporated into his performance.
Producer Paul Gregory brought the project to Laughton after working with him on theatrical productions. The American Film Institute's catalogue cites contemporary reports that Gregory optioned Grubb's first novel for $10,000 before its publication. A January 1954 publishing report described a further $75,000 payment, plus a share of profits, if the option was exercised. Gregory planned a continuing production business, with two films annually and Laughton remaining associated with it. This was also Gregory's first feature as a producer. Production designer Hilyard Brown and editor Robert Golden also appear in AFI's production credits.
The completed film received its world premiere in Gregory's hometown of Des Moines, Iowa, on July 26, 1955, as a benefit for the local YMCA. AFI records a parade, a local proclamation honouring Gregory and a Tonight Show telecast among the premiere activities. The film's early reviews varied. Some reviewers criticized Laughton's inexperience or the picture's strained simplicity, while others praised its performances and found the work provocative. Those contemporary responses were more varied than an account of unanimous rejection would suggest.
The production photographs preserved in the BFI's selection document a different atmosphere from the film's threatening screen world. In one image, Sally Jane Bruce, who played the young Pearl Harper, handles a viewfinder alongside Laughton. Another shows the director down on the floor trying a shot with cinematographer Stanley Cortez.
Cortez recalled working with Laughton as one of his most exciting experiences in cinema. Further photographs show Mitchum talking with his director between takes and preparing the early prison scene with Peter Graves. The prison encounter establishes the connection between Powell and the stolen fortune. Mitchum's right-hand tattoo spelling LOVE is visible in one of the informal images. These production views preserve the actor away from the finished performance while retaining a costume detail integral to his character's public display of righteousness.
Critic Peter Rainer reads Laughton's achievement as an elaborate children's fable. In his assessment, the picture draws on earlier cinematic traditions while combining menace with an unusually disturbing kind of humour. Children recognize Powell's danger while many adults accept the appearance he presents. Rainer identifies a heightened purity in the imagery, with darkness and enchantment carrying the force of a story experienced through childhood. His interpretation concerns the finished film's tone and symbolism, distinct from the contemporary production reports assembled by AFI.
The children's river journey gives that interpretation a concrete setting. Rainer describes their small boat framed by large foreground images of frogs, caged birds, spider webs and rabbits. Walter Schumann's music contributes to the atmosphere. Rachel Cooper later confronts Powell as a formidable counterweight, yet the opposition is complicated by their shared singing of Leaning on the Everlasting Arms. Rainer treats that nocturnal duet as an example of the film's refusal to keep darkness and light in wholly separate compartments. The Library of Congress added the film to the National Film Registry in 1992.
Geoff Andrew similarly emphasizes the film's mixture of American pastoral settings and Expressionist imagery. He identifies older devices such as iris shots within Cortez and Laughton's sharp black-and-white compositions. Andrew also compares particular images with the paintings of René Magritte, while presenting that connection as his own visual response. Small West Virginia towns on the Ohio River during the Great Depression become the setting for this stylized drama. The familiar locations and furnishings acquire a threatening quality through their treatment on screen.
Andrew's admiration includes a reservation about a few scattered moments that border on broad comedy, which he is unsure whether to attribute to the star, the director or both. He regards them as a slight tonal discrepancy within an otherwise remarkable achievement. That judgment differs from Rainer's emphasis on the unsettling humour as a central strength. Andrew also records that Laughton intended to film Norman Mailer's The Naked and the Dead, but the commercial failure of The Night of the Hunter ended those plans.
Later critical recognition gave the production a very different place in film history. In the BFI's 2022 Sight and Sound results, The Night of the Hunter shared 25th place in the critics' poll and 41st in the directors' poll. The BFI record credits James Agee with the screenplay and Paul Gregory with production, alongside Laughton's directing credit.
- The Night of the Hunter (1955): directing credit and critical record, BFI — www.bfi.org.uk
- American Film Institute, The Night of the Hunter (1955): production and release history — catalog.afi.com
- Behind the scenes: The Night of the Hunter, BFI production photographs — www.bfi.org.uk
- Peter Rainer, The Night of the Hunter, reproduced by the Library of Congress — blogs.loc.gov
- Geoff Andrew, The single flaw that stops The Night of the Hunter short of perfection, BFI — www.bfi.org.uk