A Think Again Media Group publication
Movie Stumper

Which ducks would you hear dueling at these pianos?

Donald Duck and Daffy Duck: the voices and drawings behind the piano encounter

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Movie Stumper

Donald Duck and Daffy Duck: the voices and drawings behind the piano encounter

Donald Duck and Daffy Duck share the dueling-piano act in Who Framed Roger Rabbit. Disney's 1988 release brought the two studio personalities into one performance, alongside the separate meeting of Mickey Mouse and Bugs Bunny. The vocal rivalry accompanied an unusually intricate combination of filmed action and drawings.

The American Film Institute's cast record gives the ducks their performers: Tony Anselmo voiced Donald and Mel Blanc voiced Daffy. Blanc also supplied Bugs Bunny, while Wayne Allwine supplied Mickey Mouse. Charles Fleischer played the voice of Roger himself. These credits distinguish the animated guests from the actors speaking for them. Donald Duck's screen partner belonged to Warner Bros., but the voices heard in their shared scene belonged to particular performers, each credited for an individual character.

Anselmo's explanation of Donald's voice, preserved in his Disney Legends profile, emphasizes muscle control. He described developing strength while holding his mouth in the required position so that he could concentrate on acting. Maintaining the sound was only the preparation for a performance. His remarks help place the distinctive squabble in the piano encounter: Donald Duck needed to remain vocally recognizable while responding to another character. The profile specifically includes Who Framed Roger Rabbit among Anselmo's film performances and dates his continuation of Donald's voice to 1985.

Don Hahn described another kind of preparation in D23's release history. Zemeckis first cut a live-action film in which performers addressed a rabbit that would be added later. For objects handled by Roger, a puppeteer could move a prop using a rod from beneath a table. The animators then drew Roger's hand over the support. Hahn explained that the need to conceal the rod sometimes made the hand look stiff. Physical manipulation established movement that the drawings had to accommodate.

After the live-action edit, the material passed through a turnover discussion about each scene. Hahn recalled receiving stacks of photostats, photographic reproductions made frame by frame from the footage. Punched along the bottom, they fitted onto pegs so the animation could be drawn into the photographed scene. The duck duet belonged to a film whose drawn performances were coordinated with an already photographed world through precisely registered images.

Amblin's production record identifies Richard Williams as animation director, Dean Cundey as cinematographer and Ken Ralston as visual-effects supervisor. Arthur Schmidt edited, and Alan Silvestri composed the score. Those credits put the finished sound and images within several separate crafts. Amblin describes a Hollywood and Toontown populated by human performers and animated guests, naming both ducks among its cameos. The familiar characters shared a screen with Bob Hoskins, Christopher Lloyd and Joanna Cassidy. A brief musical encounter formed one part of that larger constructed community, rather than a separate cartoon inserted before the feature.

Anselmo had learned Donald Duck's voice directly from Clarence Nash, its original performer. His Disney profile recalls an initially casual request to Nash to demonstrate the technique. Practice in the car and shower eventually produced the sound, and Nash began tutoring him seriously. Anselmo spent three years developing it before Nash's death in 1985. He had entered Disney as an animator; in 1990's The Prince and the Pauper, he became the first person to animate and voice Donald. His work crossed the distinction between drawing a performance and recording one.

Williams likewise described learning through direct contact with experienced animators. In a 2013 interview with Dan Sarto for Animation World Network, he recalled employing Ken Harris and Art Babbitt over many years and having Grim Natwick tutor artists at their desks. He had also studied films by tracing their drawings. These were practical forms of training in movement, carried into his own animation work. Discussing Who Framed Roger Rabbit, Williams singled out a shot he animated in the opening cartoon, with Roger emerging from the refrigerator, as the moment he felt sure the film would succeed.

That opening-shot memory is Williams's later judgment of his own work. Sarto's 2013 coverage places it within a two-hour Academy masterclass and an exhibition organized around subjects including walks, flexibility and dialogue. Cartoon performance could be examined as a sequence of physical and expressive decisions. The exhibition's subjects separated elements of the animator's work so they could be studied through examples of movement and speech. Between the recording booth and the animation desk, an established personality had to become a fresh performance in a particular scene.

The completed film's awards recognized several parts of that coordination. Amblin records Oscars for film editing, sound-effects editing and visual effects, plus a Special Achievement Award for animation direction. These were honors for the feature's crafts as a whole. The record distinguishes the shaping of the film's rhythm from its sound effects, visual effects and animated performances. Williams's animation honor stands alongside the visual-effects award. The feature recognized by those separate categories includes the brief meeting of Disney's duck and his Warner Bros. rival at the keyboards.

The Question

Who plays the dueling-piano act in Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

Show the answer

The Answer

Donald Duck and Daffy Duck. Disney's Donald and Warner Bros.' Daffy share the act in the 1988 film. The movie also puts Mickey Mouse and Bugs Bunny together, turning familiar studio neighbors into actual scene partners.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Movie Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.