A Think Again Media Group publication
Movie Stumper

Can you spot how those Harry and Sally couples were made?

When Harry Met Sally: The Couples Behind the Stories

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Movie Stumper

When Harry Met Sally: The Couples Behind the Stories

In When Harry Met Sally, those courtship stories came from real people, but actors performed the versions seen on screen. They accompanied Billy Crystal and Meg Ryan as Harry Burns and Sally Albright, whose relationship unfolds through meetings, separations and renewed contact in New York. Harry and Sally first meet in Chicago and share a drive east. Over twelve years, their chance encounters lead them from that journey into friendship and a more complicated romantic relationship.

Rob Reiner traced the idea for the older couples to dinner at the home of Alan Horn, a partner at Castle Rock. Horn's parents were there, and his father Sol had been quiet. Reiner asked how he had met his wife. Sol recalled seeing a woman enter a Horn and Hardart restaurant while he was with a friend and announcing that he would marry her. Two weeks later, they were married, and fifty years afterward they were still together. Reiner said that recollection became the first courtship story heard in the film, turning a dinner conversation into a cinematic beginning.

The interludes in When Harry Met Sally developed during Nora Ephron's screenwriting work. When she did not feel like writing, she interviewed people at the production company. Some of their stories entered the movie between scenes after being rewritten and filmed with actors. Finding a title was another part of the development. Ephron originally wanted How They Met and considered several alternatives. During filming, Reiner offered a case of champagne to any crew member who came up with the title. His earlier dinner inspiration and Ephron's proposed name both focused on the beginnings of relationships, a subject shared by the interludes and the central romance.

The larger project began with conversations about single life and friendship. Reiner and Ephron met at the Russian Tea Room in New York, where a proposed courtroom drama failed to interest her. His ideas about men, women, friendship and sexual attraction did. He initially called the project Scenes from a Friendship, echoing Ingmar Bergman's Scenes from a Marriage. Ephron interviewed Reiner about relationships, and he asked about her perspective in return. She developed drafts over several years while he directed Stand by Me and The Princess Bride, with their continuing exchanges helping the script take shape between those other productions.

Real behavior also shaped the central friendship in When Harry Met Sally. Crystal had observed his friend Reiner's return to single life after divorce, material that helped prepare him for Harry. Ephron based Harry partly on interviews with Reiner and producer Andrew Scheinman, while Sally drew on Ephron and some of her friends. A split-screen scene in which Harry and Sally talk by telephone while watching television came from something Crystal and Reiner did every night. The friends' habit became an onscreen exchange, giving the fictional pair an activity borrowed from the lives of people making the film.

Sally's restaurant ordering came from another encounter close to the production. At lunch, Ephron asked for dressing on the side and specified changes to her meal. Reiner wanted that behavior in the movie, making detailed food requests a trait Ryan could perform. At Katz's Delicatessen, Ryan played Sally faking an orgasm during lunch with Harry. Crystal contributed the punchline, "I'll have what she's having," which Reiner gave to his mother Estelle. She agreed to appear, looking forward to spending the day with her son and eating a hot dog. After restrained early takes, Reiner demonstrated the scene, and Ryan performed it more fully.

Reiner's own romantic life changed the film's ending. The earlier version had Harry and Sally meet years later on a New York street, converse pleasantly and then walk away separately, seen from a high angle. During the making of the movie, Reiner met Michele Singer and fell in love. Their relationship led him to change that outcome. In the finished story, Harry declares his love at a New Year's Eve party, and the couple marry three months later. The director's experience thus affected the destination of the central romance as well as the conversations and observations that had helped launch it.

When Harry Met Sally opened in 1989, with Columbia Pictures initially releasing it in selected cities before widening distribution. Its music included standards performed by Harry Connick Jr., with big-band and orchestral arrangements by Marc Shaiman. Connick received his first Grammy for best male jazz vocal performance. Ephron won the BAFTA for original screenplay and received an Academy Award nomination. The film later reached the stage in a 2004 production with Luke Perry and Alyson Hannigan. In 2022, the Library of Congress selected it for the National Film Registry, giving the romantic comedy a place in the national preservation collection.

The Question

In When Harry Met Sally, who delivers the older couples' courtship stories seen between scenes?

Show the answer

The Answer

Actors retelling real couples' courtship stories. The filmmakers collected genuine courtship accounts, then used actors to present scripted versions. The stories had real roots even though the people telling them on screen were performing.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Movie Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.